Home     Contact Us         Log in

book reviews - Category Archive

Oct 29
Friday

Book Review: Cynicism and Magic

Filed under book reviews

Cynicism and Magic
Intelligence & Intuition on the Buddhist Path
By Chögyam Trungpa

Review by Christine Heming

The talks transcribed and edited in this book are based on the inaugural class that Naropa’s founder, Chögyam Trungpa, offered in the summer of 1974.  They are the product of a new generation of editors working under the mentorship of Trungpa Rinpoche’s principal editors, Carolyn Gimian and Judith Leaf.  When I started to read Cynicism and Magic I wondered if these written words would capture the directness, power, and brilliant clarity I felt when I heard these talks for the first time, and I remember that time well.

Our small dharma study group gathered in the living room of Jacquie and Tom Bell’s home in Annapolis Royal, Nova Scotia, to listen to audiotapes of the original 1974 Naropa talks.  We were mesmerized.  At one point, a woman in our group abruptly leaped up on the sofa on which she had been sitting and blurted out, “He’s brilliant.” 

I needn’t have worried.  The teachings in this book are direct, powerful, and clear; it is a page-turner – fresh, alive, and magical.  No matter how many books you have read by Chögyam Trungpa, this volume will add clarity to what you already know, and reintroduce you to many dharma principles with words and phrases that differ slightly from what you may have read elsewhere.  For example, in presenting spiritual materialism, Trungpa Rinpoche emphasizes using our intelligence – a critical attitude exiting in you, which is not based on logic or intellect, but is experiential and intuitive.  In this context he responds to a question about spirit with, “ . . . let us build our spirit.  Spirit, in this case, is a sense of inquisitiveness . . .”

In another chapter Rinpoche discusses egolessness from the Hinayana point of view, and calls it “direct egolessness,” which is based on feeling:  “ . . . learning how to feel, not ignoring how we feel, and not regarding what we feel as bad or good . . . feeling as we feel, fearlessly.”  Egolessness in this sense is not a theoretical or philosophical concept; it is how we feel about our existence – that we don’t have substance, that everything is suffering, and that we are unable to grasp onto anything.

I appreciated the presentation on the skandhas in chapter three.   Although brief, there is a simplicity and clarity to what can seem so complex.  He links spiritual materialism to the first skandha:  “It’s the nonexistence of one’s basic ground, the nonexistence of the first skandha that cuts through the rest of it [the other skandhas]. . . That’s why it is important to understand spiritual materialism.  Otherwise, you cannot even begin on the spiritual path.”

In another chapter, Rinpoche talks about mediation within the context of surrendering.  We must have some understanding of what we are doing and why we practice meditation or our practice may be pure deception.  He makes it clear that if we are on the spiritual path, we must sit and meditate.  Other activities, like swimming or walking in the woods, while they might have a meditative quality, are not powerful, honest, or genuine enough to lead to awakening.  Meditation is a question of simplicity, and of unlearning and undoing.  There is an element of spiritual materialism there of course, but it is relatively harmless: “It just lives by itself, and dies by itself, through the simple technique of putting awareness on the breath . . .”

Of the Hinayana or “narrow” path, Rinpoche says, “The shape of the path is narrow, but it is shaped by our openness to it, which may be extraordinarily wide and willing.”  But no matter how open we are, we need to embrace the discipline and practice of facing ourselves. It is a process of surrendering or “slimming down,” being willing to give up any kind of hope and become a worthy vessel. 

Once we feel completely at home and settled in our discipline, there is a need to develop a more open mind and be challenged to relate to the world.  This is the “open” or Mahayana path.  He compares these two paths this way:  “ . . . the hinayana path is like water that collected in a cow’s footprint in the mud, and the mahayana path is the ocean.”   He tells us that the bodhisattva-warrior attitude to work with all sentient beings and surrender your own desire for enlightenment doesn’t make sense.  It can only be understood by realizing emptiness, “ultimate nothingness.”  You are nowhere, but it is fantastically good.  “The only way bodhisattvas keep functioning is through a sense of warmth and compassion for themselves and others.”

Rinpoche elaborates on the disciplines of the open path.  I particularly liked the way he talks about patience – both the discipline of being without expectations as well as how we manifest expectation psychologically in everything we do.  He gives this example:  “Before we get something we want, we begin to shape ourselves. . . If we want an espresso, for example, between the time we order it . . . and when we get it, we soften ourselves.  We shape ourselves into ‘an espresso coffee drinker.’ We become that way.  We give in, . . . and if we don’t get what we expected, . . . we attack.”

There’s a chapter comparing the Tibetan and Zen traditions, both of which work toward developing basic sanity.  Once again, Rinpoche warns of spiritual materialism, which can arise within either tradition particularly when we focus our training on the cultural behaviours or the esthetics of the tradition rather than its basic sanity.  

In the chapter on the “fourth moment,” Rinpoche clarifies what the “gradual” and “sudden” paths to enlightenment mean.  In essence, a gradual process is taking place constantly; any sudden glimpse can only occur because of that gradual process.  He tells us “ . . . we could say quite safely that there is no such thing as sudden enlightenment in Buddhism at all.”

The final chapters touch on the notion of genuine poetry and song, on nirvana or freedom, and on the real magic of actual existence – all of which are full of discoveries.  I highly recommend Cynicism and Magic; it might be a good choice for a book study of the buddhist path.


Christine Heming is a writer and educator.  She has been a student of the buddhadharma for over 45 years, and a senior teacher and meditation instructor in Shambhala.  She lives in Port Royal, Nova Scotia.

Entries filed under book reviews


My Grandmother’s Hands: Racialized Trauma and the Pathway to Mending Our Hearts and Bodies

My Grandmother’s Hands: Racialized Trauma and the Pathway to Mending Our Hearts and Bodies – HIGHLIGHT

By Resmaa Menakem Reviewed by Christine Heming . . . trauma and healing occur fundamentally in the body, not in the cognitive mind. My Grandmother’s Hands was first published in 2017 and again in 2021 in a UK Penguin Books edition.  Its first publication escaped me and I cannot recall ... continue
Posted September 24, 2021 by Natasha West
The Wild Edge of Sorrow

The Wild Edge of Sorrow – HIGHLIGHT

By Francis Weller Reviewed by Sara Demetry The work of the mature person is to carry grief in one hand and gratitude in the other and to be stretched large by them.  Francis Weller, www.thesunmagazine.org/issues/478/the-geography-of-sorrow Grief around the loss of my mother at age 28 is what turned my mind ... continue
Posted September 3, 2021 by Natasha West
Jairam Ramesh's New Book Looks At The Poem That Defined The Buddha

Jairam Ramesh’s New Book Looks At The Poem That Defined The Buddha – HIGHLIGHT

Reposted from The Tribune India by Amitabha Bhattacharya Here is a book on a book — a biography of Edwin Arnold’s portrayal, in verse, of Siddhartha Gautama’s evolution as the enlightened Buddha — authored by one of India’s more sensible public figures. How ‘The Light of Asia’ ... continue
Posted August 31, 2021 by Natasha West
From a Mountain in Tibet

From a Mountain in Tibet – HIGHLIGHT

From a Mountain in Tibet: A Monk’s Journey Written by Lama Yeshe Losal Rinpoche Reviewed by Kristine McCutcheon On a dateless day in the time of COVID, a dear monastic friend dropped this book off at my door. “You will like it!” she smiled. As a student of ... continue
Posted August 11, 2021 by Natasha West
Authenticity in Intention and Action

Authenticity in Intention and Action – HIGHLIGHT

Social Presencing Theater: The Art of Making a True Move by Arawana Hayashi Reviewed by Elaine Yuen In these busy and distracted times, finding authenticity in intention and action can be challenging. It seems that every moment we are called to react to our world with likes, distrust, or ignorance. Arawana ... continue
Posted August 6, 2021 by Natasha West
A Book of Luminous Things - An International Anthology of Poetry: Edited with an Introduction by Czeslaw Milosz

A Book of Luminous Things – An International Anthology of Poetry: Edited with an Introduction by Czeslaw Milosz – HIGHLIGHT

A Book of Luminous Things – An International Anthology of Poetry Edited with an Introduction by Czeslaw Milosz Reviewed by Christine Heming Before you print a poem, you should reflect on whether this verse could be of use at least to one person in the struggle with himself and ... continue
Posted July 30, 2021 by Natasha West
The Age of Waiting: By Douglas J. Penick

The Age of Waiting: By Douglas J. Penick – HIGHLIGHT

The Age of Waiting Heart Traces & Song Lines in the Anthropocene Reviewed by Christine Heming The world’s vividness is fading before our eyes. . . . We are offered a bleak future with mass starvation, mass migration, and new plagues.  We are hearing about the end of a ... continue
Posted July 2, 2021 by Rose_Keyes
THE REALM OF SHAMBHALA by Shar Khentrul Jampel Lodrö

THE REALM OF SHAMBHALA by Shar Khentrul Jampel Lodrö – HIGHLIGHT

Review and Brief Commentary by Christine Heming Shambhala is . . . the ultimate manifestation of peace and harmony. It is the realization … of those two qualities and the revelation of their capacity. Like the sun hidden behind clouds, every so often we can get a ... continue
Posted May 11, 2021 by archives-staff
THE REALM OF SHAMBHALA (Part Two)

THE REALM OF SHAMBHALA (Part Two)

Review and Brief Commentary by Christine Heming Part 2: The realm of Shambhala and the Kalachakra Tantra The Historical Shambhala What of Shambhala the realm? Does it exist? Khentrul Rinpoche addresses these questions in part to point out that “the key to manifesting Shambhala is recognizing that it is ... continue
Posted May 11, 2021 by archives-staff
Yasodhara and the Buddha: a novel by Vanessa R. Sasson

Yasodhara and the Buddha: a novel by Vanessa R. Sasson – HIGHLIGHT

Reviewed by Christine Heming This is the story of Yasodhara, the woman who was married to the one who became the Buddha. . . . After countless lifetimes of shared experiences, he abandoned her without even saying goodbye. . . on the very day she gave birth! Vanessa ... continue
Posted March 15, 2021 by archives-staff
a wild love for the world

A Wild Love for the World: Joanna Macy and the Work for Our Time – HIGHLIGHT

Edited by Stephanie Kaza Book review by Christine Heming As an activist, Buddhist scholar, general systems thinker and deep ecologist, Joanna Macy’s work is far-reaching.  Many know her for creating “The Work That Reconnects” and “The Great Turning,” and with her husband Fran, a real-world vision of nuclear ... continue
Posted January 16, 2021 by archives-staff
Preparing to Die by Andrew Holocek

Preparing to Die by Andrew Holocek – HIGHLIGHT

Reviewed by Christine Heming Recently several books have appeared written by well-regarded teachers on the Tibetan Buddhist approach to death and dying.  These add to a growing collection of teachings, practices and guidance for the dying and for their caregivers. One might ask if we need yet ... continue
Posted September 18, 2020 by archives-staff
Primordial Grace by Robert and Rachel Olds

Primordial Grace by Robert and Rachel Olds – HIGHLIGHT

a book review by Don Beamish In 1997 artists Robert and Rachel Olds felt the call to enter into a meditation retreat that lasted for nine years and changed their lives forever.   It is quite clear that they emerged from retreat with profound realization. Primordial Grace: Earth, ... continue
Posted July 10, 2020 by archives-staff
Spacious Minds by Sara E. Lewis

Spacious Minds by Sara E. Lewis – HIGHLIGHT

From Cornell University Press Review by Shastri Steve Gleich Have you ever wondered what it would be like to grow up and live in a Buddhist culture? Would you view the truths of the dharma as common sense? One would be indeed fortunate to be part of a ... continue
Posted June 16, 2020 by archives-staff
Dakini Power by Michaela Haas

Dakini Power by Michaela Haas – HIGHLIGHT

A review by Christine Heming Michaela Haas has shared with us her “labor of love” by honoring the lives and accomplishments of twelve female pioneers of Buddhism in the West . . . and these are remarkable women.  As individuals they are direct, determined, sharp, humorous, courageous ... continue
Posted May 4, 2020 by archives-staff

RSS feed for the book reviews category

View all posts from authors in book reviews: natasha_west Rose_Keyes alexvangils



Website Development by Blue Mandala using Wordpress MU.
All content and source Copyright © 1994-2021. Shambhala International (Vajradhatu), Shambhala, Shambhala Meditation Center, Shambhala Training, Shambhala Center and Way of Shambhala are registered service marks of Shambhala USA
Privacy Policy
Translate »